Committed to connecting the world

Roundtable on SDG 9 and 17: Partnerships for inclusive and sustainable digital development

​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​​

The Roundtable on SDG 9 and 17 “Partnerships for inclusive and sustainable digital development" of the Regional Forum on Sustainable Development for the UNECE Region took place on 29 March 2023 from 15:00 to 18:00 CET. It was held in a hybrid format, online and in WMO Premises in Geneva, Switzerland. The Roundtable was co-organized by the International Telecommunication Union (ITU) and the World Meteorological Organization (WMO), with the contributions of UNEP, UNIDO and UN Women.

The need to address green and digital transitions jointly and the link that those two notions hold is of growing importance in the Europe and Central Asia region and became a defining characteristic to reach the 2030 Agenda. The UN75 Declaration and its subsequent Common Agenda deployed by the UN Secretary-General António Guterres calls on renewed efforts to improve digital cooperation and to protect the planet. Those two notions are brought together under the UN SG Roadmap for Digital Cooperation which addresses Digital Environmental Sustainability. The Global Digital Compact, proposed under the Common Agenda and informed by the Roadmap, will be agreed upon at the Summit of the Future in September 2024 which reviews the progress made on the UN75 Declaration.

In light of the above, this roundtable shared policy recommendations and actions to support an inclusive and green digital transformation. It looked at factors hindering internet connectivity access and use across communities and locations. It discussed the importance of robust digital infrastructure as a prerequisite for the successful uptake of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) solutions serving climate action. Overall, the roundtable  reviewed the achievements made on SDG 9 and 17 indicators related to internet connectivity access and use, ICT infrastructure, innovation, and the development, transfer, and dissemination of environmentally sound technologies. Recognizing the need for strengthened digital cooperation, this roundtable emphasized a systemic approach to digital development. Collaboration between the ICT and the Environment sectors is even more so crucial to a successful environmentally-sound digital development.  ​​​​​​​​​​​​​

Guiding questions

​The roundtable discussion was guided by the following questions:

  1. What are the key solutions to developing robust and reliable ICT infrastructure that can provide universal, affordable, and safe internet connectivity?
  2. What are effective policies and actions that governments can implement to limit the negative impact of the manufacturing and use of digital and ICT solutions and devices on the environment, such as e-waste generation, greenhouse gas emission, or loss of rare and raw earth materials?
  3. How can innovative ICT-based solutions and emerging technologies be leveraged to support governments in mitigating environmental risks and challenges?
  4. Which kind of partnerships are needed to achieve this objective and what are the effective mechanisms that can be leveraged?

Problem statement

The UN75 Declaration and its subsequent Common Agenda deployed by the UN Secretary-General António Guterres calls on renewed efforts to improve digital cooperation and to protect the planet. Those two notions are brought together under the UN SG Roadmap for Digital Cooperation which addresses Digital Environmental Sustainability. The Global Digital Compact, proposed under the Common Agenda and informed by the Roadmap, will be agreed upon at the Summit of the Future in September 2024 which reviews the progress made on the UN75 Declaration. In parallel, the link between green and digital transitions, and the necessity to address them jointly, is growing in importance for actors in the Europe and Central Asia region. 

In light of the above, this roundtable will share policy recommendations and actions to support an inclusive and green digital transformation. It will look at factors hindering internet connectivity access and use across communities and locations. It will discuss the importance of robust digital infrastructure as a prerequisite for the successful uptake of Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs) solutions serving climate action. Overall, the roundtable will review the achievement made on SDG 9 and 17 indicators related to internet connectivity access and use, ICT infrastructure, innovation, and the development, transfer, and dissemination of environmentally sound technologies. Recognizing the need for strengthened digital cooperation, this roundtable will emphasize a systemic approach to digital development. Collaboration between the ICT and the Environment sectors is even more so crucial to a successful environmentally-sound digital development.   

Digital solutions catalyze innovative economic development, help create jobs, advance quality education, boost competitiveness, and can improve the lives of citizens everywhere. However, the benefits of digital development are not yet available to all. The UN universal meaningful connectivity targets, recently approved by the UN Secretary General's Envoy on Technology, complement the SDGs and set the objective to ensure universal access to connectivity and use of the Internet, enhanced affordability of broadband Internet access, and digital literacy by 2030. While Western European countries have already reached universal 4G coverage, Eastern European and Central Asian countries still have an approximative 10% gap in 4G coverage, and about 2% of the population is not covered by mobile networks at all (SDG target 9.c.1). Besides, the regional gap in fixed broadband subscriptions is widening (SDG target 17.6.2). The number of Internet users is steadily growing, but there is still a 13% usage gap in the Western part of the region and an 18% gap in the Eastern part of the region that needs to be bridged (SDG target 17.8.1).  These statistics prove the need for continued, renewed, and concerted actions to ensure affordable and meaningful access to ICT devices for all, including girls and women, and vulnerable populations.  The digital gender divide in access to devices and the Internet remains significant, and this gap is even wider when introducing the concept of meaningful access to connectivity.  The Commission on the Status of Women, in its Agreed Conclusions for CSW67, “underscored  that rapid technological change, including new and emerging digital technologies, has an impact on women's employment opportunities and can accelerate progress towards achieving gender equality and the empowerment of all women and girls in the context of climate change, environmental and disaster risk reduction policies and programmes and facilitate efforts to promote and protect human rights and fundamental freedoms, as well as bridge digital divides both between and within countries". 

On our way to this objective, we must consider and limit the negative impact of the manufacturing and use of digital and ICT solutions and devices on the environment. Such negative externalities include greenhouse gas emissions, energy or water consumption, loss of raw and rare earth materials, and electronic waste generation. Ensuring a circularity of electronics is necessary to handle what the UN now calls a 'tsunami of e-waste'. Electrical and Electronic Equipment (EEE) constitutes one of the fastest-growing streams of physical waste in today's global environment. 

According to the latest UN Global E-Waste Monitor, in Europe, 12.0 million tonnes (16.2 kg per capita) of e-waste were generated in 2019, of which 42.5% have been documented to be collected and properly recycled. For the CIS Regions, available data suggests 5 million tonnes (8.7 kg per capita), with the reported collection rate being only 3.2%. If not properly recycled or treated, this waste can threaten people's health and well-being and create untold pollution. Extending the life of electronic products and re-using electrical components is also key for economic development, allowing the saving of valuable materials and rare earth materials. Collection and recycling operations can also create new employment, economic activity, education, and trade. 

While more electronic devices are part of the problem, they also can be a big part of the solution.  Digital and ICT solutions and devices constitute tremendous opportunities for sustainable development. They are central to providing real-time and actionable insights into the state of the planet. Internet connectivity is a prerequisite to gathering data, which in turn plays an important role in supporting climate change mitigation and adaptation actions, benefiting nature protection and ecosystem restoration, as well as improving monitoring and decision-making capacities. Digital solutions can also play a critical role in making the implementation of environmental regulation more efficient and thus aiding enforcement efforts, such as through producer registration, online auditing and reporting, data collection and sharing, smart contracts and real-time accounting software.​

Agenda

[15:00-15:05]​

Welcome 

Overview of the session and the UN Digital Transformation Group for Europe and Central As​​ia  

[15:05-15:25]

Introductory remarks by the co-organizers​​


Building block 1: Universal access to internet connectivity

Question 1: What are the critical solutions to developing robust and reliable ICT infrastructure that can provide universal, affordable, and safe connectivity?​

[15:25-15:30]

Keynote – Commission on the Status of Women (CSW)

Ensuring gender-responsive digital development through inclusive and sustainable partnerships: Regional commitments from the Action Coalition on Technology and Innovation for Gender Equality of the Generation Equality Forum and the 67th Session of the Commission on the Status of Women.

[15:30-16:00]

Roundtable discussion

The roundtable discussion will bring stakeholders to discuss the policy actions and recommendations needed to ensure internet connectivity, access, usage, affordability, and digital inclusion for everyone and in all places.

Moderator: Jaroslaw Ponder, Head, ITU Europe Office

[16:00-16:15]

In-depth case studies

The in-depth case studies will provide concrete examples of initiatives that may be scaled up in the region to achieve this objective.

[16:15-16:20]

Q&A and wrap-up of building block 1

The floor will be open to questions from the audience.

Building block 2: Green and digital - Sustainable digital transformation and digital transformation for sustainability

Question 2: What effective policies or actions can governments implement to manage e-waste and make ICT and digital solutions and devices circular and sustainable?

Question 3: How can innovative ICT-based solutions and emerging technologies be leveraged to support governments in mitigating environmental risks and challenges?

[16:20-16:25]

Keynote speaker

[16:25-16:55]

Roundtable discussion

This roundtable will bring stakeholders to discuss the policy actions needed to foster the circularity and sustainability of electronic devices, and manufacturing. It will also shed light on digital solutions' role in climate change mitigation and adaptation. 

 Moderator: Vanessa Grey, Head, Emergency Telecommunication and Environment Unit, ITU

[16:55-17:15]

In-depth case studies

The in-depth case studies will provide concrete examples of initiatives that may be scaled up in the region. On the one hand, reduce and manage negative externalities of ICTs on the environment, and on the other hand, capture the benefit of ICTs for climate change mitigation and adaptation. 

[17:15-17:20]

Q&A and wrap-up of building block 2

The floor will be open to questions from the audience.

[17:20-17:30]Break

​Building block 3: Innovative partnerships toward inclusive and sustainable digital development

Question 4: Which kind of partnerships are needed to achieve this objective, and what are the effective mechanisms that can be leveraged?​

 

[17:30-17:50]

Moderated session

Based on the insights gained throughout the roundtable, this concluding segment will bring regional and national actors to reflect jointly on the partnerships and mechanisms needed to foster inclusive and sustainable digital development.

Moderator: Natalia Mochu, Regional Director, ITU Regional Office for CIS

[17:50-18:00]

Wrap up of the Peer Learning Round Table and concluding remarks