Committed to connecting the world

WTISD

Meeting results (2018-07-09~20)

​​​​​​​​​​Results from previous meeting(s): 2018-022017-102017-01
2016-052015-102015-02 2014-06  2013-10 2013-01
2012-05 2011-11 2011-03 2010-07 2009-10 2009-01
2008-04 2007-06 2006-11 2006-04 2005-07 2004-11
2004-01 2003-05 2002-10

SG16 Closing Plenary room​​

Executive Summary of the ITU-T Study Group 16 Meeting
(Ljubljana, Slovenia, 9-20 July 2018)

​​​Numbers and other links​

Major accomplishments

Collocated acti​​vities:

Dates of next SG16 meeting and interim Working Party meetings

The two subsequent meetings of SG16 are planned as follows: NOTE – These dates are subject to change, in particular due to the SG16 decision to shorten the SG16 meetings [TD143/Plen from the Macau meeting]. ​

Map of meeting reports & Liaison Statements (as seen by the SG16 Plenary)

 
Plen WP1 WP2 WP3
Meeting ReportQ1: TD201/Plen
JCA MMeS: TD200/Plen
FGs: TD196/Plen (AI), TD197/Plen (VM)
Qs: TD198/Plen (MM-AI), TD199-R2/Plen (MM-DLT)
TD202-R3/Plen
TD203-R1/Plen
TD204/Plen
Liaison Statements
(28 in total)
Q1:TD205-R1/Plen (3)
 
TD206/Plen (6) TD207-R2/Plen (14) TD208/Plen (5)
Work programme TD209-R1/Plen TD210/Plen TD211/Plen​

 List of Participants:SG16-TD170-R1/Plen

Summary of Questions' Results

Question 1/16 summary

Question 1/16 met in two sessions, the main activity being to review a number of documents addressed to Q1/16 and to all SG16 Questions, to determine what action, if any, is required. Input was also solicited via email from Rapporteurs who were unable to attend these sessions. Out of these documents, three outgoing liaison statements were prepared. No interim meetings ate planned.

​Question 6/16 summary

The primary goals for Question 6/16 at this meeting of SG16 were to review the progress of Q6/16, JVET, JCT-VC, and JPEG work. It reached AAP Consent on revised Rec. H.265.1 (V3) Conformance specification for ITU-T H.265 high efficiency video coding and Rec. ITU-T T.88 (V2) Information technology – Lossy/lossless coding of bi-level images (common text with ISO/IEC 14492). A substantial portion of the image coding work of Question 6/16 has been conducted jointly with ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 1 (JPEG/JBIG), and a substantial portion of the video coding work of Question 6/16 is being conducted jointly with ISO/IEC JTC 1/SC 29/WG 11 (MPEG) in two joint collaborative teams known as the Joint Video Experts Team (JVET) and the Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC). Meetings of JVET and JCT-VC were held in a collocated fashion with this meeting of SG16 under its auspices. JVET is tasked with development of Versatile Video Coding (VVC), a future video coding standard with substantially improved coding efficiency relative to HEVC. A joint discussion session was held with MPEG and Q6/16 at this meeting to coordinate the video compression standardization work. Q6/16 is planning to hold up to four Rapporteur meetings, two JVET meetings, and two JCT-VC meetings before the next SG16 meeting in March 2019 and to hold meetings of JVET and the JCT-VC in a collocated fashion with the next SG16 meeting in March 2019 under its auspices. The Question prepared one outgoing Liaison Statement to MPEG.

Question 7/16 summary

While dealing with some discrepancies between the description of G.722.2 and the corresponding AMR-WB codec previously reported by Q7/16, 3GPP SA4 uncovered some additional minor discrepancies in the capitalisation of certain table names. SA4 therefore asks ITU-T SG16 to implement corresponding changes in G.722.2 in order to maintain alignment with AMR-WB. Q6/16 agreed to undertake this task, and a corrigendum to G.722.2 Annex C is proposed to harmonise the two codec specifications (SG16-TD212/Plen). A reply LS was sent to 3GPP SA4 to keep them informed. The question plans no interim meetings.

Question 8​/16 summary

Question 8/16 completed three work items for Consent: ITU-T H.430.1 (ex H.ILE-Reqs) "Requirements for Immersive Live Experience (ILE) services", H.430.2 (ex H.ILE-FW) "Architectural framework for immersive live experience (ILE) services", and ITU-T H.430.3 (ex H.ILE-SS) "Service scenario of immersive live experience". Draft H.ILE-MMT: Service configuration, media transport protocols, signalling information of MMT for ILE was also progressed. The Question prepared three outgoing Liaison Statements and plans to hold one interim meeting before the next SG16 meeting.

Question 11/16 summary

Question 11/16 had a successful meeting and worked on progressing the revisions of ITU-T H.230 and H.243.  Q11/16 submitted for Consent the text for a revision to the common text ITU-T Rec. H.222.0 | ISO/IEC 13818-1 and reviewed several items in the plan for future work. The Question does not plan to hold any interim Rapporteurs meeting.

Question 13/16 summary

Question 13/16 progressed the work on six draft new Recommendations: ITU-T H.IPTV-AM.2, ITU-T H.IPTV-SBM, ITU-T H.IPTV-TDES.6, ITU-T H.761(V4) and ITU-T H.IPTV-MAFR.14. The Question agreed to start three new work items: ITU-T H.IPTV-LSFA "Layered specification for the IPTV service platform functional architecture based on open service capabilities", ITU-T H.IPTV-PS "Application event handling: Overall aspects of personalized IPTV service", and HSTP-IPTV-VRS "IPTV roaming service based on virtualized IPTV terminal device". The Question prepared two outgoing Liaison Statements, and the group completed work on ITU-T H.766 (ex H.IPTV-MAFR.14), "Lua for IPTV services". The group plans to hold one interim meeting before the next SG16 meeting in March 2019.

Question 14/16 summary

Question 14/16 received seven contributions for its current work items. It also discussed six contributions addressed to all Questions including the proposal to establish new Questions and new FGs under SG16. Q14/16 finalized the work on new ITU-T Rec. H.783 (ex H.DS-AM) and ITU-T Rec. H.785.1 (ex H.DS-PISR) and proposed them for Consent. Q14/16 is planning to hold Rapporteur group meetings in September and October 2018; consent of H.DS-DCI is planned at an interim WP1/16 plenary collocated with the latter Q14/16 meeting. The Question prepared one outgoing LS to inform various relevant groups of the work completed on these new digital signage Recommendations.

Question 21/16 summary

Question 21/16 met for ten sessions during this meeting. A total of 39 contributions were received and discussed. Seventeen ongoing work items were progressed and updated based on discussion at the meeting. The Question agreed to submit six draft new Recommendations for Consent and one technical paper for Approval. The Question agreed to start ten new work items at this meeting and plans on holding one interim Rapporteurs meeting in November 2018, collocated with Q24/16. Q21/16 produced two reply LSs jointly with Q24/16 on S2ST and a reply LS to SG12 on performance metrics for CDNs.

​Question 24/16 Summary

Question 24/16 met for two sessions, under the chairmanship of Ms Miran Choi (ETRI, Korea). The Question also held joint sessions with Q21/16 and Q28/16. The group discussed four contributions and agreed to create three new work items: F.HF-SLM, F.UI-SH and F.HF-BC. Question 24/16 and Question 21/16 agreed to send two liaison statements regarding E.FAST to ASTAP EG-MA and ISO JTC1/SC35. The Question plans one interim meeting collocated with Q21/16 in November 2018.

Question 26/16 summary

Question 26/16 received eleven contributions. The group agreed to propose two technical papers for approval: ITU-T FSTP-ACC-RCS (ex FSTP.RCSO) "Overview of remote captioning services" (New) and FSTP-CONF-F921 (ex FSTP-ANS-Checklist) "Compliance procedure and requirements for audio-based indoor and outdoor network navigation system for persons with vision impairment". It also agreed to the Consent of two revised Recommendations, ITU-T F.791 (Accessibility vocabulary) and ITU-T F.921 (Navigation for persons with visual impairment). The group agreed to initiate one new work item on information service system for visually impaired persons and to reopen three work items: ITU-T H.702 Rev (Accessibility Profiles for IPTV), FSTP.ACC-AM (Accessible meeting) and FSTP.ACC-RemPart (Remote Participation). Q26/16 produced 11 output documents including four outgoing liaison statements. The Question plans two interim meetings.

Question 27/16 summary

Question 27/16 reviewed one contribution in detail related to the creation of a new Work Item F.VS-AIMC "Use cases and requirements for multimedia communication enabled vehicle systems using artificial intelligence", which was accepted and a baseline produced. Additionally two contributions on the creation of new Focus Groups in SG16 were discussed. The Question reviewed three incoming liaison statements and drafted two reply LS. Q27/16 plans one Rapporteur group meeting in Geneva in November 2018, collocated with other SG16 Questions.

Question 28/16 summary

Q28/16 received 24 contributions, and agreed to propose 15 documents for Consent at this meeting. It produced 22 output documents including seven outgoing liaison statements. Six new and seven revised Recommendations of the H.820-H.850 were consented, bringing the conformance testing specifications for the Continua Design Guidelines in line with the latest edition ("Keratin"). The Question also completed the initial work on a specification for safe listening using personal music systems, developed together with WHO, ITU-T H.870 (ex F.SLD). The Question also Consented another Recommendation on Framework for telemedicine systems using ultra-high definition imaging. The Question plans two interim meetings.

Recommendations Consented by SG16 on the closing Plenary

Title Doc.*​ AAP/L​​C**
ITU-T F.743.5 (ex H.CDN-FI) "Framework and interfaces for multimedia content delivery network" (New) TD226/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T F.743.6 (ex F.NG-CDN) "Service requirements for next generation content delivery networks" (New) TD191-R2/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T F.746.7 (ex F.IQAS-META) "Metadata for Intelligent Question Answering Service" (New) TD192-R1/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T F.746.8 (ex F.USMReqs) "Requirements for unified status monitoring of networks and services" (New) TD230/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T F.780.1 (ex F.Med-UHD) "Framework for telemedicine systems using ultra-high definition imaging" (New) TD232/PlenAAP-41
ITU-T F.791 "Accessibility terms and definitions" (Rev.) TD227/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T F.921 "Audio-based indoor and outdoor network navigation system for persons with vision impairment" (Rev.) TD224/PlenAAP-40
​ITU-T G.722.2 (2003) Annex C (2017) Cor.1 "Corrections to Table C.5​" (New) TD212/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.222.0 | ISO/IEC 13818-1 (Ed.7) "Information technology - Generic coding of moving pictures and associated audio information: Systems" (Rev.) TD193/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.265.1 (V3) "Conformance specification for H.265 high efficiency video coding" (Rev.) TD228/PlenAAP-43
ITU-T H.430.1 (ex H.ILE-Reqs) "Requirements for immersive live experience (ILE) services" (New) TD219/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.430.2 (ex H.ILE-FW) "Architectural framework for immersive live experience (ILE) services" (New) TD220/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.430.3 (ex H.ILE-SS) "Service scenario of immersive live experience" (New) TD221/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.626.3 (ex H.VSSIArch) "Architecture for visual surveillance system interworking" (New) TD225/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.626.4 (ex H.P2PVSArch) "Architecture for point-to-point visual surveillance system" (New) TD222/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.766 (ex H.IPTV-MAFR.14) "Lua for IPTV services" (New) TD190-R1/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.783 (ex H.DS-AM) "Digital signage: Audience measurement services" (New) TD213-R1/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.785.1 (ex H.DS-PISR) "Digital signage: Service requirements and a reference model on information services in public places via an interoperable service platform" (New) TD215/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.820 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Conformity assessment test plan" (New) TD176/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.830.13 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Services interface Part 13: Capability Exchange: Health & Fitness Service sender" (New) TD177/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.830.14 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Services interface Part 14: Capability Exchange: Health & Fitness Service receiver" (New) TD178/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.830.15 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Services interface Part 15: FHIR Observation Upload: Health & Fitness Service sender" (New) TD179/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.830.16 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Services interface Part 16: FHIR Observation Upload: Health & Fitness Service receiver" (New) TD180/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.841 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 1: Optimized Exchange Protocol: Personal Health Device" (Rev.) TD182/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.842 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 2: Optimized Exchange Protocol: Personal Health Gateway" (Rev.) TD183/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.843 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 3: Continua Design Guidelines: Personal Health Device" (Rev.) TD184/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.844 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 4: Continua Design Guidelines: Personal Health Gateway" (Rev.) TD185/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.845.17 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 5Q: Power status monitor" (New) TD181/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.845.2 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 5B: Glucose meter" (Rev.) TD186/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.846 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 6: Personal Health Gateway" (Rev.) TD187/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.849 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 9: Transcoding for Bluetooth Low Energy: Personal Health Devices" (Rev.) TD188/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T H.870 (ex F.SLD) "Guidelines for safe listening devices/systems" (New) TD231/PlenAAP-40
ITU-T T.88 | ISO/IEC 14492 (2nd edition) "Information technology - Lossy/lossless coding of bi-level images" (Rev.) TD195/PlenAAP-40
Notes:  
*: some texts are subject to editorial clean-up before posting. Hence, the version posted may differ from the TD indicated. These texts are planned to start Last Call about eight weeks after the SG16 meeting​.
**: expected AAP Announcement for Last Call.

Recommendations Approved by SG16 on the closing Plenary (according to A.8 §5)

None at this meeting.

Recommendations Decided by SG16 on the closing Plenary

None at this meeting.

Other texts approved by SG16

 ​

Technical Papers Doc.
ITU-T FST-CONF-F921 (ex FSTP-ANS-Checklist) "Compliance procedure and requirements for audio-based indoor and outdoor network navigation system for persons with vision impairment" (New) TD223/Plen
ITU-T FSTP-ACC-RCS (ex FSTP-RCSO)​ "Technical Paper: Overview of remote captioning services" (New) TD229/Plen
ITU-T HSTP-DIS-UAV "Technical Paper: Use cases and scenarios for disaster information service using unmanned aerial vehicles" (New) TD194-R3/Plen

* NOTE - No Appendices, Supplements, Implementors Guides or Technical Reports were approved at this SG16 meeting.

Recommendations agreed for deletion by SG16

None at this meeting.

Updates in the SG16 management team and Rapporteurs

(Click her​e for the complete list of SG16 Rapporteurs)

Resignations and departures:

New Appointments:

Representatives and other roles:

In addition to the SG16 representatives continuing in their functions, the following were appointed:
S​ee the webpage for the latest inf​ormation.

Open positions:

Annex A - Question 5/16 (Q.MM-AI) - Artificial intelligence-enabled multimedia applications

Motivation

The recent success of Artificial Intelligence (AI) in various applications has raised study and utilization of AI technology to a new height. AI has been the apex technology of the information age. One of the most exciting aspects of the AI inflection is that “real-world” use cases abound. At the same time, deep-learning enabled advances in computer vision and such technologies as natural language processing are dramatically improving the quality of people’s work and life.
At present, the ecological pattern of AI has been established gradually. In future years, specialized intelligent applications will be the main potential area for the future development of AI. No matter whether it is a specialized or generalized application, the enterprise layout of AI will focus on three basic levels; data, computing layer (base), algorithm layer (technology) and application layer. AI is not just “tech for tech”. Where large data sets are combined with powerful enough technology, value is being created and competitive advantage is being gained.
Multimedia has become the pioneer, and the concept of “AI-enabled Multimedia” as well as “Intelligent Multimedia” has already come up. Scientists, engineers all over the world are delving into some of the most exciting areas such as computer vision and speech technologies. Computers are being taught to understand video, augmenting reality to guide field technicians when operations get complex, helping computers recognize people, detect sentiment and speak with emotion, and enrich video with metadata extracted from it.
AI-enabled multimedia applications are booming, but focused studies are far behind. Emerging technologies brings not only new opportunities, but also new challenges as well as new demands. Taking multimedia data as an example, image, video and sound data are the fuel of AI applications such as recognition, sentiment classification, etc. However, huge volume multimedia data does not indicate high quality labelling data that AI applications could benefit. No guidelines or standards of multimedia format, labelling are developed, multimedia data collected and labelled by company A could not be used in company B, which results in huge resource waste and prevent the data flow, which severely hindered the development of AI industry.
This Question focusses on artificial intelligence-enabled multimedia applications, to identify challenges facing the deployment of AI-enabled multimedia applications, to analyze the impact of AI technologies in standards for multimedia applications, and to identify evaluation and assessment specifications of service, algorithm and data for standards in AI -enabled multimedia applications, in order to boost and innovate the development of multimedia as well as AI industry.

Study items

Study items to be considered include, but not limited to:

NOTE – The study of this Question should take into account safeguards and ethics issues of AI-enabled multimedia applications and algorithms 

Tasks

Tasks include, but not limited to:

Other topics can also be studied, as appropriate, based on contributions.

Relationships

Recommendations

Questions

Study Groups

Other bodies

Annex B - Draft new Question 22/16 (Q.MM-DLT) - Distributed ledger technologies and e-services

Motivation

A distributed ledger is a consensus of replicated, shared, and synchronized digital data geographically spread across multiple sites, countries, or institutions. There is no central administrator or centralized data storage.
Distributed ledger technologies (DLT) are secure by design and exemplify a distributed computing system with high Byzantine fault tolerance. Decentralized consensus has therefore been achieved with a DLT system. This makes DLT potentially suitable for the recording of events, medical records, and other records management activities, such as identity management, transaction processing, documenting provenance, food traceability, and voting.
A range of standardisation-related and industry initiatives have commenced across the globe examining different aspects of DLT/Blockchain. Various activities, including exploratory workshops and cross-industry collaboration initiatives, such as the Hyperledger project have served as forums for discussion of potential technical challenges around the widespread adoption of DLT.
An ITU-T Focus Group on Application of Distributed Ledger Technology (FG DLT), was established May 2017 under the auspices of TSAG. The focus group addresses a number of topics of DLT, for example, use-cases and applications, requirements for the implementation, regulatory and policy aspects, security and privacy aspects, among many other aspects.
ISO/TC 307 develops standards on DLT/Blockchain based on the market need.
ITU-T SG16 is a leading group of e-services and multimedia applications. DLT technology has a good potential of new technology and multimedia applications that needs trusted infrastructure. SG16 does not have the explicit group to discuss the above problems.
This Question develops Recommendations on Distributed Ledger Technologies and DLT based e-services.

Study items

Study items to be considered include, but not limited to:

NOTE – This Question will take into consideration identified policy and regulatory implications of application of DLT in multimedia applications and e-services.

Tasks

Tasks include, but not limited to:

Other topics can also be studied, as appropriate, based on contributions.

Relationships

Recommendations

Questions

Study Groups

Other bodies