Committed to connecting the world

WTISD

SG16 results (Virtual Geneva, 26 June - 3 July 2020)

Executive Summary of the ITU-T Study Group 16 Meeting
(Virtual Geneva, 22 June - 3 July 2020)

Results from previous meeting(s): 2019-10 2019-06 2019-03 2018-10 2018-07 2018-02 2017-10 2017-01
2016-05 2015-10 2015-02 2014-06 2013-10 2013-01
2012-05 2011-11 2011-03 2010-07 2009-10 2009-01
2008-04 2007-06 2006-11 2006-04 2005-07 2004-11
2004-01 2003-05 2002-10

20191017-SG16-Closing_plen-Animation.gif

Numbers and other links

Major accomplishments

Collocated activities:

Dates of next SG16 meeting and interim Working Party meeting

Map of meeting reports & Liaison Statements (as seen by the SG16 Plenary)


Plen
WP1/16 WP2/16 WP3/16
Meeting Report
JCA MMeS: N/A
TD401-R1/Plen
TD402-R2/Plen
TD403-R1/Plen
Liaison Statements
(28 in total)
TD405-R1/Plen (10)
TD406-R1/Plen (8)
TD407-R1/Plen (7)
Work programme

TD408/Plen
TD409/Plen
TD410/Plen
QuestionsMandate: TD411-R1/Plen
Q1: TD412/Plen
TD413/Plen
TD414-R1/Plen
TD415/Plen

List of Participants: TD388-R1/Plen IPR: TD380-R3/Plen

Summary of Questions' Results

Question 1/16 summary

Question 1/16 oversees general coordination across the various SG16 Questions and external groups. It reviewed a number of general incoming liaison statements in two sessions, and three replies were generated. In preparation for WTSA-20, the text of the Question was reviewed, but no further changes were made relative to the version revised at the previous meeting.

Question 5/16 summary

Question 5/16 met for ten sessions during the SG16 meeting to discuss the use of AI in multimedia and reviewed 18 contributions. Work was completed for ITU-T F.748.11 "Metrics and evaluation methods for deep neural network processor benchmark". The Question also progressed on existing work items (F.AI-MLTF, F.AI-SCS, F.AI-DLFE, and F.SCAI) and agreed to start ten new work items (F.IMCS, F.Supp-OCAIB, F.SBNG, F.AI-SF, F.AI-DMPC, F.AI-RMCDP, F.AI-MKGDS, F.AI-FASD, F.AI-ILICSS, and F.REAIOCR). The Question produced one outgoing liaison statement and plans on holding two meetings in the interregnum period.

Question 6/16 summary

Question 6/16 met for four sessions during the SG16 meeting, with primary goals to review the progress of Q6/16, JVET, JCT-VC, and JPEG work. Q6/16 completed two new Recommendations for AAP Consent on topics related to the coding of video and still images (H.266 "Versatile video coding" and H.274 "Versatile supplemental enhancement information for coded video bitstreams"). Q6/16 also submitted a new Technical Paper (H-series TP HSTP-VID-WPOM) for Approval, describing working practices using objective metrics for evaluation of video coding efficiency experiments. A substantial portion of the image coding work of Question 6/16 is conducted jointly with ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG 1 (JPEG), and a substantial portion of the video coding work of Question 6/16 is being conducted jointly with ISO/IEC JTC1/SC29/WG 11 (MPEG) in two joint collaborative teams known as the Joint Video Experts Team (JVET) and the Joint Collaborative Team on Video Coding (JCT-VC). Meetings of JVET and JCT-VC were held via teleconference in alignment with this meeting of SG16 under its auspices. JVET is tasked with development of Versatile Video Coding (VVC), a future video coding standard with substantially improved coding efficiency relative to H.265/HEVC and the associated Versatile Supplemental Enhancement information (VSEI, H.274) and JCT-VC is tasked with maintenance and enhancement of H.265/HEVC, H.264/AVC and CICP (H.273). A joint session with MPEG was also held, to assist in the coordination of the work. Now that H.266/VVC reached its Consent milestone, the Question proposes merging the joint collaborative video teams into JVET as a single platform, incorporating the maintenance work for MPEG-2/Video, H.264/AVC and H.265/HEVC. Q6/16 is planning to hold two Rapporteur group meetings (collocating with meetings of JVET) in the interregnum period. It is also expected that a meeting of JVET will be held in a collocated fashion with the next SG16 meeting in April 2021 under its auspices. The Question prepared five outgoing Liaison Statements.

Question 7/16 summary

Question 7/16 did not hold any sessions during this SG16 meeting. The Question is planned to be merged into Question 6/16 in the new study period.

Question 8/16 summary

Question 8/16 focus met for five sessions during the SG16 meeting to discuss immersive live experience (ILE) topics addressed in four contributions and several liaison statements. As the result, Q8/16 completed work on draft Recommendation H.430.5 (ex H.ILE-PE). During Q8/16 meeting, candidate future work items and the Question description were updated. In addition, Q8/16 agreed to send one liaison statement to various organizations informing on the Consent of H.430.5. The Question does not plan to hold any meetings in the interregnum period.

Question 11/16 summary

Question 11/16 did not meet during this ITU-T SG16 meeting. No interim activity is planned and it will progress its work items at the next meeting of SG16.

Question 12/16 summary

Question 12/16 on video surveillance met for twelve sessions to review fourteen contributions. During the sessions, experts completed work on three draft Recommendations: H.627 V2, F.735.1 (ex F.SDC) and F.743.11 (ex F.MPUVSReqs). Q12/16 updated its terms of reference for the next study period with the updated title "Intelligent visual systems and services". The Question progressed its various work items including H.VSECArch and F.BVSSI. Q12/16 agreed to start five new work items (F.TSVSN, H.P2PVSProt, H.SDC, F.IVS-CRM and H.HVSProt). Q12/16 debated the various ways forward of F.FRAVSReqs on facial recognition; there was no consensus reached and this issue remains open. Contributions are invited for further discussion on this topic at the next meeting of Q12/16. The Question plans on holding one interim (e-)meeting in November 2020 and produced four outgoing liaison statements.

Question 13/16 summary

Question 13/16 on IPTV systems and services progressed the work on three draft Recommendations (H.IPTV-LSFA, H.IPTV-TDES.6 and H.IPTV-TMRAPI) and completed work on ITU-T H.704 (ex H.IPTV-EUIF.1) on an enhanced user interface framework using gesture controls. The Question started no new work items. The Question prepared three reply outgoing Liaison Statements. The group plans to hold an interim meeting in October or November 2020, in addition to two e-meetings. The group also discussed the Question scope and terms of reference together with Q14/16, and agreed to continue the existing open digital signage studies in Q13/16 in the next study period. The scope of the Question will also cover content delivery networks (CDN) and accordingly will receive some work items previously addressed in Q21/16.

Question 14/16 summary

Question 14/16 mainly discussed the preparation for the merger with Q13/16 at the next study period in 2021-2024, and completed for Approval the text of Technical Paper HSTP.DS-Gloss with a glossary on digital signage. Three work items will be continued under Q13/16 in the next study period (H.DS-ASM, H.DS-CASF and H.DS-FIS). Q14/16 agreed to discontinue the now obsolete HSTP.DS-WDS on web-based digital signage. The Question did not prepare any outgoing liaison statements and will not hold any meetings in the interregnum period.

Question 21/16 summary

Question 21/16 experts met for ten sessions during this meeting to discuss multimedia framework, applications and services addressed in 19 contributions. Work completed on six draft new Recommendations and the Question agreed to start five new work items. Three outgoing LSs were prepared and two work items were discontinued at this meeting. Q21/16 plans to hold an interim meeting together with other SG16 Questions in the November 2020 timeframe. The Question agreed on nominating Ms Nijingnan Zhang (China Unicom, China) to be an Associate Rapporteur, who will assist the Rapporteur in the management of liaison statements.

Question 22/16 summary

Question 22/16 on distributed ledger technologies and e-services was addressed in seven sessions to progress its various work items. Q22/16 completed work on three draft new Recommendations: ITU-T F.751.0 (ex F.DLS), ITU-T F.751.1 (ex F.DLT-AC) and ITU-T H.751.2 (ex H.DLT), and there were two new work items created, F.DLT-FIN "Financial distributed ledger technology application guideline" and HSTP.DLT-Risk "DLT-based Application Development Risks and their Mitigations". Experts proposed continuation of the Question in the next study period with the same mandate. The Question plans one interim Rapporteur group meeting and produced one outgoing liaison statements at this meeting. The Question proposed holding a series of interactive webinars ("meet-ups") involving DLT technology developers, service providers, research institutions, United Nations agencies, regulators, and other related professionals to increase collaboration with the global DLT community and build on the network of experts developed by the now closed FG-DLT, and identify new standardization areas that could be pursued by Q22/16. More details here.

Question 23/16 summary

Question 23/16 had its inaugural session at this meeting of SG16, with its newly adopted text and Rapporteur, Mr Hong (Norman) Chen (BUPT, China), and Associate Rapporteur, Mr ShiZhong Xu (UESTC, China). Experts met for four sessions during this meeting and agreed to start new work on ITU-T F.DC-CGS-FRA (Reference framework for cloud gaming system), ITU-T F.DC-CRATS-Meta (Metadata for cultural relics and artworks tracing system based on block chain), ITU-T F.DC-IRS-RA (Reference Architecture for an Image Recognition System for Cultural Relics and Artworks), ITU-T F.DC-MTCPS (Reference architecture for mobile terminal computational photography system). The Question also received related work items previously allocated to Q21/16: F.DICHE-RC, F.CGS-RAS, F.ARMSMeta, F.ARMS and F.DECRM. The Question prepared a reply LS to MPEG. Q23/16 plans to hold an interim meeting together with other SG16 Questions in the November 2020 timeframe.

Question 24/16 summary

Question 24/16 on human factors was addressed in four sessions to review six Contributions and various liaison statements. During the sessions, the Question progressed on several work items and completed work on three draft new Recommendations: ITU-T H.862.1 on a data model for the sleep management services, ITU-T H.862.2 on annotation methods for biosignal data and ITU-T H.862.3 on requirements of voice management interface for human-care services. There was one new work item created at this time, on a framework for defining readiness level of AI technology with respect to human factors. Experts proposed continuation of the Question in the next study period as "Human factors for intelligent user interfaces and services". The Question produced no outgoing liaison statements at this meeting and plans on holding one interim meeting.

Question 26/16 summary

Question 26/16 on ICT accessibility was addressed in eight sessions to review 11 contributions and a number of Liaison Statements. Work was completed on ITU-T H.702 (V2) on accessibility profiles for IPTV systems and ITU-T F.922 (ex F.ACC-ISSVReq) on requirements of information service system for visually impaired persons. Work was also completed for a twin text resulting from Q26/16 collaboration with ISO/IEC SC35 "User interfaces", ITU-T T.701.11 (ex H.ACC.AltText) | ISO/IEC 20071-11, that provides guidance on text alternatives for images. The Question also completed work for two Technical Papers, FSTP.ACC-WebVRI with guideline on Web-based remote sign language interpretation (VRI) and FSTP.ACC-ALD with an overview of assistive listening systems.

Question 27/16 summary

Question 27/16 deals with vehicular Gateway telecom platforms in intelligent transportation systems. There were six contributions addressing Q27/16 work items and two of them proposed the creation of a new Question on vehicular multimedia. After discussion of the latter proposal in a plenary ad hoc group, it was agreed to merge the proposed new vehicular multimedia work items into Q27/16. The modified ToR for the Question was reviewed and adopted for the next study period. The six contributions to Q27/16 included one related to F.VS-AIMC and three related to F.VM-URVMN. Work was completed on the latter as ITU-T F.749.3 "Use cases and requirements for the vehicular multimedia networks", which is the first deliverable from the ITU-T FG-VM. Work started on a new ITU-T F.VG-AD-Reqs on information requirements for automated driving, and on a Technical Paper FSTP.SS-OTA with a survey on over-the-air updates. There were ten incoming liaison statements to the Question and it prepared three outgoings LSs: one LS announces the Consent of F.749.3 (ex F.VM-URVMN) to ITU-T SGs and related SDOs, one reply LS to ETSI TC ITS, and one to SG17 and CITS on the new Technical Paper FSTP.SS-OTA. Q27/16 plans to meet in two interim Rapporteur group meetings and during the next SG16 meeting in April 2021. JVDS will also meet during these three meetings.

Question 28/16 summary

Q28/16 met to discuss safe listening, brain informatics, UHD medical imaging and personal connected health devices as well as new work items. The Question forwarded eight revised Recommendations in the Personal Health Systems conformance testing series (H.841, H.850.1 to H.850.7) for Consent. It agreed to create seven new work items on telemedicine and digital health. The Question will hold three virtual interim meetings on safe listening and another one on general Q28/16 topics. No outgoing LSs were produced.

Recommendations Consented by SG16 on the closing Plenary

Title Doc.* AAP/LC**
ITU-T F.735.1 (ex F.SDC) "Requirements for software-defined camera" (New)
TD431/Plen AAP-85
ITU-T F.743.11 (ex F.MPUVSReqs) "Requirements for video surveillance with mobile premises units" (New)
TD435-R1/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.743.20 (ex F.AFBDI) "Assessment framework for big data infrastructure" (New)
TD417/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.743.21 (ex F.DAM) "Framework for data asset management" (New)
TD418/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.746.10 (ex H.LLS-DIA) "Architecture for spontaneous dialog processing system for language learning" (New)
TD420/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.746.11 (ex F.IQAS-INT) "Interfaces for Intelligent Question Answering Service" (New)
TD419/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.748.11 (ex F.AI-DLPB) "Metrics and evaluation methods for deep neural network processor benchmark" (New)
TD439-R1/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.749.12 (ex H.CUAV-F) "Framework for communication application of civilian unmanned aerial vehicle" (New)
TD421/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.749.3 (ex F.VM-URVMN) "Use cases and requirements for the vehicular multimedia networks" (New)
TD441/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.751.0 (ex F.DLS) "Requirements for distributed ledger systems" (New)
TD436/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.751.1 (ex F.DLT-AC) "Assessment criteria for distributed ledger technologies" (New)
TD437/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.751.2 (ex H.DLT) "Reference framework for distributed ledger technologies" (New)
TD451/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T F.922 (ex F.ACC-ISSVReq) "Requirements of information service systems for visually impaired persons" (New)
TD448/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.266 (ex H.VVC) "Versatile video coding" (New)
TD445/Plen
AAP-87
ITU-T H.274 (ex H.SEI) "Versatile supplemental enhancement information messages for coded video bitstreams" (New)
TD446-R1/Plen
AAP-87
ITU-T H.430.5 (ex H.ILE-PE) "Reference models for ILE presentation environment" (New)
TD447/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.627 (V2) "Signalling and protocols for a video surveillance system" (Rev.)
TD396/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.644.3 (ex H.MCDN) "Functional architecture of multimedia content delivery networks" (New)
TD422/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.702 (V2) "Accessibility profiles for IPTV systems" (Rev.)
TD443/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.704 (ex H.IPTV-EUIF.1) "Enhanced UI framework for IPTV terminal device - Gesture control interface" (New)
TD438/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.841 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 1: Optimized Exchange Protocol: Personal Health Device" (Rev.)
TD423/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.850.1 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 10A: Transcoding for Bluetooth Low Energy: Personal Health Gateway - Thermometer" (Rev.)
TD424/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.850.2 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 10B: Transcoding for Bluetooth Low Energy: Personal Health Gateway - Blood pressure" (Rev.)
TD425/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.850.3 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 10C: Transcoding for Bluetooth Low Energy: Personal Health Gateway - Heart-rate" (Rev.)
TD426/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.850.4 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 10D: Transcoding for Bluetooth Low Energy: Personal Health Gateway - Glucose meter" (Rev.)
TD427/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.850.5 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 10E: Transcoding for Bluetooth Low Energy: Personal Health Gateway - Weighing scales" (Rev.)
TD428/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.850.6 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 10F: Transcoding for Bluetooth Low Energy: Personal Health Gateway - Pulse oximeter" (Rev.)
TD429/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.850.7 "Conformance of ITU-T H.810 personal health system: Personal Health Devices interface Part 10G: Transcoding for Bluetooth Low Energy: Personal Health Gateway - Continuous glucose monitoring" (Rev.)
TD430/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.862.1 (ex F.DM-SLM) "Data model for sleep management services" (New)
TD432/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.862.2 (ex F.AM-BS) "Framework of annotation methods for biosignal data" (New)
TD433/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T H.862.3 (ex F.VMI-HS) "Requirements of voice management interface for human-care services" (New)
TD434/Plen
AAP-85
ITU-T T.701.11 (ex H.ACC.AltText) | ISO/IEC 20071-11 "Guidance on text alternatives for images" (New)
TD440/Plen
AAP-87
Notes:
*: some texts are subject to editorial clean-up before posting. Hence, the version posted may differ from the TD indicated.
**: expected AAP Announcement for Last Call.

Recommendations Approved by SG16 on the closing Plenary (according to A.8 §5)

None at this meeting.

Recommendations Decided by SG16 on the closing Plenary

None at this meeting.

Other texts approved by SG16


Technical Papers Doc.
ITU-T FSTP.ACC-ALD "Overview of assistive listening systems" (New) TD450/Plen
ITU-T FSTP.ACC-WebVRI "Guidelines on web-based remote sign language interpretation" (New)
TD449/Plen
ITU-T HSTP.DS-Gloss "Digital signage: Glossary and definitions" (New)
TD398/Plen
ITU-T HSTP-VID-WPOM "Working practices using objective metrics for evaluation of video coding efficiency experiments" (New)
TD444/Plen

NOTE 1 - No Appendices, Supplements, Implementors' Guides or Technical Reports were approved at this SG16 meeting.

Recommendations agreed for deletion by SG16

None at this meeting.

Updates in the SG16 management team and Rapporteurs

(Click here for the complete list of SG16 Questions and Rapporteurs/Associate Rapporteurs)

Resignations and departures:

New Appointments:

Representatives and other roles:

In addition to the SG16 representatives continuing in their functions, the following were appointed:
See the webpage for the latest information.

Open positions:


​​